Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Public Displays of Parenting

meet your (weird) nurse

It's not like I didn't see it coming. We spend a lot of time on public transportation, and Zinashi takes every ride as her opportunity to pepper me with questions, knowing that there is little to distract me unless the baby is trying to crawl off my lap or I get a time sensitive text message. She's asked about why there are boogers in our noses and what makes people smell different. She's asked why someone who was wearing tights as pants didn't know about privacy. But until last night, questions about how babies are made have been confined to times we are at home.

We approach questions about biological functions of all sorts pragmatically. We answer the question she's asking, and if it is about a more grown up topic, we do not offer additional information about the subject beyond exactly what she's asked. So I'd told her already that two parts have to go together to make a baby, the egg from the woman and the sperm from the man. She didn't ask how that happened, so I stopped there.

Last night at dinner, she found out that a friend's mom is pregnant, and so naturally she had more questions. Being exceptionally inquisitive, she simply couldn't wait to ask more questions. On the N, on our way home, she started in immediately. She began by asking about the egg. Why doesn't it come out of the mom before the baby comes out? Does it have a shell? So it's not like the eggs we eat? I was hoping to keep that line of questioning coming until we got home, but no.

There was a pause.

Uh-oh.

She sighed, looked up at me, and said, "I just need to know exactly how the parts go together from the mom and the dad to put the baby in the tummy."

I obviously wasn't going to answer her in front of everyone on the train. But I had to give some sort of answer...in front of everyone on the train. So I told her that just like there are parts of our bodies that are private, there are some things that happen that make a baby that are private, so we will talk about it at home.

So far today, she hasn't asked about it again. I do intend to bring up the subject. Not-quite-six years old is not the time I thought I'd be having the birds and bees talk with her, but I don't want her to feel awkward or ashamed about the subject. I want her to know that if she has a question, I will answer it.

What I recall about my own conversation with my mother about how babies come to be is that she put me off for a long time, and then it was embarrassing. We didn't really talk about those things in our family. I think that was the way it was for a lot of families. But if I want my daughters to feel comfortable asking questions and bringing concerns to me, I need to remove the awkwardness and make it clear that this is nothing to be embarrassed about. 

Right now Zinashi has a healthy sense of openness within our family and boundaries outside our family. When faced with an I'll-show-you-mine-if-you-show-me-yours situation, she did exactly the what I taught her to do and said no, told me what happened, and wasn't embarrassed. I want to keep things this way. I also want to give her a healthy respect for her body and for the bodies of others, for the things they can do, and the responsibilities surrounding all those things, including making a baby. Even though I hadn't anticipated discussing this subject just yet, I think it's good. I think she's ready.

Now I just have to put my own learned sense of embarrassment aside and tell her what she needs to know. I won't be approaching the s*x for pleasure angle, just the mechanics of making the baby. Like I said before, I answer the question she's asking and don't give her a lot of additional information. I know that she will have more questions as time goes by, and by allowing her to ask those and giving an answer readily and without making a big deal of it, she will learn all she needs to know in a way that is (hopefully) natural and comfortable for both of us.

You know, if she'll just stop asking those questions on public transportation.




13 comments:

  1. Great response! I sometimes forget and try to answer questions they aren't asking. Or, correct an assumption that doesn't really need correcting - like the dad in the cartoon, sure he's sleeping (not dead at all). I want to be open too and sometimes push the openness. I really like your approach. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You handled that amazingly well! Most of the
    time simple answers will suffice so kudos for the honesty to her! You have two beautiful and amazing girls!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have a lot of Big Thoughts on this. As a non-parent of course, I can usually pass the buck by saying, "That's a great question to ask Mommy when she gets home!" (you're welcome!) and have only had the mechanics talks with one child.

    The experience I had growing up was the same experience I gave that child (her mother and I have discussed this and she's happy to pass the buck to me - I'm not educating random children about town), which is that this is an on-going discussion that gets more in-depth the older you get. I have had this discussion on the bus twice (kids love to play the 'is that lady pregnant or fat?' guessing game).

    My mother never gave me One Big Talk. She kept the book "How Did I Get Here" and "What's Happening To Me?" on her nightstand and we were welcome to take them any time we wanted, all through our childhoods.

    Having said all that, I can't help but wonder if Z has perhaps witnessed a birth or two in her younger years in Ethiopia where giving birth in hospitals is more rare, and just doesn't remember it?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Actually, I would go ahead and tell her. You should set the precedent that if she asks a question, then she's ready for an answer. Babette Cole's "Mommy Laid an Egg" and "Hair in Funny Places" are both silly but informative. This is all IMO, but she's a sharp kid with a great sense of humor. You've always done a great job making it clear that you are on her side. Flat, unexciting honesty is absolutely necessary in response to her need for answers about the big world.

    ReplyDelete
  5. We took a similar approach with my son and it has worked well so far. A book I highly recommend for this exact stage of questioning is by Paul & Kay Showers "Before you were a baby." It is scientific in its approach. It is hard to find but I in my opinion worth every penny if you can find a used copy. Kudos to you for answering so well in a public situation!!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. My older daughter was similarly very good at getting to the parts of the story we were neglecting to mention. You should check out Robie Harris' books on sex for kids. I think the first one is It's Not The Stork. They are awesome and inclusive and honest. My older daughter has worn out all three.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Gobez mom! Well played - under pressure even. That's exactly the tone I want to strike with my son.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Can't say enough to recommend this book What Makes a Baby - http://www.what-makes-a-baby.com/
    frank, informative, works at multiple ages, and most of all works for families of all kinds - super inclusive. You could even read it on the train without feeling (too) awkward!

    ReplyDelete
  9. The Robie Harris books are great. My son had lots of questions after his sister was born and I read It's NOT The Stork to him. I have the same ideas of talking about the birds and the bees now before my kids are embarassed about the topic in hopes they will continue to feel comfortable coming to me with any questions they have in the future. My son was almost 6 when we read the book.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I remember when my then four year old asked me how babies were made- I panicked a little and then went through this whole awkward long, drawn out explanation. She watched me, let me finish, and then said "Noooo. How do you make a baby out of peanut butter?" Definitely a fan of only answering what's being asked. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. ha ha ha ha... must be the Springtime coming! Our 6 six year old son (home from Ethiopia for 18 months) has been burning with questions! Very, very specific questions. We have the same policy- we give him simple, factual information without any emotional complications. Just like explaining any other bodily function. EXCEPT, he knows he's not allowed to share his newfound knowledge at school. He loves the book, "What's the Big Secret?".

    ReplyDelete
  12. Sounds like you handled it really well. The blog "71 Toes" talks a lot about how to handle this in a practical way. They have the talk with their kids at 7 or 8 I think. Might be a good place to look!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think it will be really great if you initiate this conversation back at home with her, and it'll really make her feel good that it's nothing to be ashamed about and she didn't do anything "wrong" to ask about it, which is a great foundation for her to feel good about her own body, and about her own sexuality later on. I think at her age it can be appropriate to tell her that sex is something two grown-up people do who love each other very much.

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...